Why It’s Time to Retire the Term “No-Kill”


The no-kill term and movement started in the late 1980’s and gained momentum into the
1990’s and early 2000’s. Its goal was noble; to no longer accept the routine euthanasia of
pets in America’s animal shelters due to space and the volume of pets entering shelters.
The movement wanted animal welfare organizations & leaders, communities, pet owners,
and government entities to think differently about how we treat our companion animals. By
pushing progressive ideas and targeting the issue at the source (spay/neuter) the
movement gained significant traction.


With that traction came a by-product. The identification of animal welfare organizations as
“kill” vs “no-kill” which often has led to friction and tensions between organizations. Often
organizations labeled as “kill” shelters were vilified and staff members of these
organizations were told they did not care about the pets they cared for. This led to
organizations who needed more adopters, more donors, and more volunteers to help them
improve live outcomes struggling to improve because of the public perception of their
organization as a “kill” shelter.


Many of the shelters labeled as “kill” were the ones who were taking in the highest volume
of companion animals because they did not turn them away once they were full and
regardless of an animal’s health or temperament. These organizations took the ones others
would not and in return they were vilified for the outcome those animals required to keep
the community safe and prevent animals from medically suffering.


Today, the term “no-kill” is a contentious term amongst animal welfare organizations
because of the past 30+ years. It is time to retire the term; it has served its purpose in many
communities that have evolved and changed to better serve their companion animals.
As time has passed, one thing has remained constant. The lack of a clear definition of the
term “no-kill” that animal welfare organizations and members of the public both
understand.


We are often asked, “Are you a no-kill shelter?” and our response is the same “What is your
definition of “no-kill?”


• Some people, especially members of the public, believe “no-kill” means no
animal is ever euthanized period.
• Some national organizations have labeled “no-kill” as an organization who
reaches a 90% save rate (other terms used are live release rate or placement
rate). The issue with this number is it is an arbitrary number picked without
any evidence to substantiate why it is the benchmark to be met to achieve
“no-kill status.”
• Some organizations call themselves “no-kill” if 90% or 100% of all “healthy
and treatable animals” are placed. But what is a treatable animal? That
definition could be significantly different depending on each organization’s
resources.


You can see where this can lead to a misunderstanding between organizations and the
public. Without clear definitions and understanding, conflict arises which is not in the best
interests of the companion animals in each community.


The 90% benchmark refers to the Live Release Rate/Save Rate/Placement Rate for an
organization. This number can be calculated two different ways.


• Live Outcomes (Adopted, Returned to Owner, Transferred to Another Organization
for Placement, Return to Field)/Live Intake
• Live Outcomes/Total Outcomes (Same as above but adding euthanasia, lost in care,
and unassisted death to total outcomes)
Again, this number is arbitrary without statistically evidence to support why it has been the
chosen benchmark. It isn’t based on animal health, safety, or community wellbeing. It
became a marketing benchmark — not a care standard. Yet shelters are judged, financially
supported, and publicly praised or shamed based almost entirely on that single number,
90%.


A single metric can distort decision making. When everything rides on hitting 90%,
decisions stop being about the individual animal and start being about the statistic. This
pressure can lead to keeping animals alive when they are suffering. Delaying humane
euthanasia to avoid a “negative” outcome. Placing unsafe animals back into the
community, sedating animals on the adoption floor to make them appear more adoptable
and letting animals mentally deteriorate in kennels rather than making hard but humane
decision. None of that is compassion — it’s hitting a benchmark.


As stated earlier, “no-kill” does not mean the same thing everywhere. There is no
universally accepted definition of no-kill (although some would argue it is 90%). Some
shelters don’t count neonatal kittens as intakes, some don’t count feral cats, some
reclassify shelter euthanasia as “owner-requested euthanasia” for surrenders they deem
unadoptable, some turn away sick, aggressive, or senior animals to avoid euthanasia.
Some refuse adopted pets as returns so they don’t impact their numbers.
Animal welfare must come first. Animal welfare is not just about keeping animals alive, it’s
about: quality of life, medical care & suffering, behavioral health, and community impact &
safety. Keeping an animal alive at all costs — especially when an animal is suffering is
100% inhumane. And there is a term for this, it is called “warehousing” which is a nicer way
to say “hoarding.” When you warehouse animals, you are not meeting each of their
individual medical and behavior needs, you are keeping them alive to simply keep them
alive.


We need to value honesty over numbers. Responsible organizations who report raw,
transparent data, follow clear SOPs (standard operating procedures), make decisions
based on individual animals, and accept that some years may be 88% and others 91%.
They need to focus on doing what is right for each animal — not what looks best for the
numbers. A shelter who tells the truth and prioritizes humane care is far more trustworthy
than one that protects a label at all costs. “No-kill” is not a guarantee of compassion,
sometimes it’s a marketing term, sometimes it’s a fundraising tool, and sometimes it
pressures shelters into choices that are not in the best interest of the animals or the
community. What matters more than a label/number is integrity, transparency, humane
decision-making, and accountability. Those are the things that truly protect and saves lives.
In the end an animal welfare organization should not be solely judged off one single metric.
Is it an important metric? Yes, absolutely. Does it tell the whole story? No, not at all.
Everything else an organization does to support pet owners and pets in a community
should also be considered when evaluating their impact in addition to the care they provide
to the pets entrusted to them.


At Capital Humane Society, we do not use the term “no-kill” and we never will. We do not
feel it is an appropriate term to use due to all the aforementioned items but most
importantly, we will never ask our staff to make decisions about individual animals based
on meeting an arbitrary benchmark of 90%. By forcing staff members to make a behavior or
medical decision about a pet with that number in the back of their minds, you run the risk
of the wrong decision being made. The wrong decision could mean an unsafe pet is placed
in the community where it could inflict serious harm or injury to another pet or a person or
it could mean an animal unnecessarily suffers medically or behaviorally to avoid a
euthanasia outcome.


At Capital Humane Society, we identify ourselves as a socially conscious animal shelter.
The fundamental goal of a socially conscious shelter is to create the best outcomes for all
animals. The responsibilities of a Socially Conscious Shelter include:
• Ensuring every unwanted or homeless pet has a safe place to go for shelter and
care.
• Placing every healthy and safe animal.
• Assessing the medical and behavioral needs of homeless animals and ensuring
these needs are thoughtfully addressed.
• Alleviating suffering and making appropriate euthanasia decisions.
• Aligning policy with the needs of the community.
• Enhancing the human-animal bond through thoughtful placements and post
adoption support.
• Considering the health and wellness of each animal and each community when
transferring animals between communities.
• Implementing inclusive policies and practices.
• Fostering a culture of transparency, ethical decision making, mutual respect,
continual learning, and collaboration.


In the end, the “no-kill” movement has served its purpose, especially in our community.
Significant changes have been made to improve the outcomes for pets in our shelter and
our community. But the time has come to retire the term “no-kill” and look to the future of
animal welfare in our community.

capital humane society logo white

Admissions & Assessment Center
2320 Park Boulevard Lincoln, NE 68502
(402) 441-4488 ext. 2
Monday - Friday
11:00 a.m. - 6:00 p.m.
Saturday & Sunday
12:00 - 4:00 p.m.

tiktok icon turquoisetiktok icon pink
capital humane society logo white

Pieloch Pet Adoption Center
6500 S. 70th Street Lincoln, NE 68516
(402) 441-4488 ext.1
Monday: Closed
Tuesday - Friday
11:30 a.m. - 7:00 p.m.
Saturday & Sunday
12:00 - 5:00 p.m.

stransky veterinary center logo white

Stransky Veterinary Center
5505 O Street Suite 1
Lincoln, NE 68510
402-473-5370
Monday - Friday
8:00 a.m. - 4:00 p.m.

© 2026 Capital Humane Society |
Privacy Policy |
Terms & Conditions

Site designed & developed by Baseline Creative